Choosing between composite wood and real wood is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make when it comes to building your deck, fence, or backyard oasis. At The Ultimate Deck Shop, we hear this debate almost every day—from homeowners dreaming of their first build, to contractors planning durable outdoor spaces across Saskatchewan and beyond. Let’s dig into what composite wood and real wood actually are, their unique pros and cons, and our frank opinion on which to use for different projects. As a team obsessed with building better decks (and keeping you from regretting your choice), we’ll walk you through what matters, with a focus on real-life performance for Canada’s wild weather and our customers’ diverse lifestyles.
What Is Composite Wood?
Composite wood is a manufactured material combining wood fibres (or sawdust) with plastic resins. The result is a board that mimics the look of wood but brings some serious improvements—especially when it comes to durability, lifespan, and ease of care. Modern composite deck boards feature realistic grain patterns and come in a wide range of colours. That flexibility is why you’ll see so many composite surfaces in today’s backyards. If you’d like a technical breakdown of how composites are made and the trends behind them, check out our composite decking page for more details.
- Composition: A blend of recycled wood (usually 50–65%) and plastics/resins (35–50%).
- Manufacturing: Wood and plastic are mixed, heat-molded, and extruded into perfect planks.
- Finish: Surface may feature a wood-grain emboss and UV-resistant, colour-stable outer layers.
Where Composite Wood Excels
- Decking (the most popular application by far)
- Fencing for privacy and low maintenance
- Modern patios (especially with bold colours or patterns)
- Outdoor stairs, benches, and planters where splinter-free design matters
What Is Real Wood?
Real wood refers to the boards harvested directly from trees—think cedar, pressure-treated pine, fir, or exotic hardwoods like ipe. Every board is unique, with its own grain, character, and aroma. For some, nothing rivals the authenticity, tradition, or tactile pleasure of walking barefoot across a real wood deck. Real wood continues to anchor classic and rustic outdoor builds, and enables countless finishing and staining options. As a local shop, we appreciate how proper material selection—from tight-knot cedar to budget pressure-treated boards—helps you match your project style and your budget.
- Types: Softwoods (cedar, pine, fir) and hardwoods (ipe, mahogany, oak)
- Finish Options: Untreated, pressure-treated (for durability), oiled, or stained for beauty and weather resistance
Composite Wood: Advantages and Drawbacks
Why Do So Many People Choose Composite?
- Low Maintenance: No annual staining, no sealing—just a spring cleaning with water. Learn more about this reality (and common myths) in our blog What Needs Maintenance on Composite Decks?.
- Incredible Longevity: Most composite decks last 25–30+ years, outperforming most pine or cedar builds by a significant margin.
- Consistent Looks: No warped or knotty boards, and composite colours remain stable for years.
- Weather-Proof: Impervious to rot, warping, or insect damage—even in Saskatchewan’s harshest freeze-thaw cycles.
- Sustainability: Many lines are created from recycled material, making this an eco-savvy solution if you want to minimize new resource use.
Composite: What’s the Catch?
- Higher First Cost: Composite boards can be 15–40% costlier upfront than pressure-treated pine. However, maintenance savings may make up the difference long-term.
- Heat: Composite can feel warmer under direct sun than real wood. This matters for southern exposures or poolside decks. For further reading—and solutions for hot decks—see our guide on decking trends with innovative cooling technology and color choices.
- Less Classic Charm: Engineers have come close, but some homeowners still prefer the authentic grain and feel of natural wood.
- Surface-only: Composite is used for visible parts (decking, rail caps) but not for load-bearing frames, which need real wood or metal.
Real Wood: Why It’s Still Beloved—and What to Watch For
The Magic of Real Wood
- Affordable (usually): Pressure-treated pine and spruce are budget-friendly choices for many.
- Timeless Beauty: No two boards alike. Wood’s tactile, warm feel and scent appeal to tradition and nostalgia.
- Cooler Surface: Wood generally remains comfortable in direct sun, especially compared to darker composite options.
- Endless Customization: Sand, restain, repair, or paint to your heart’s content. You can radically refresh the look years after installation.
- Sustainability Potential: If you opt for FSC-certified or local woods, you’re choosing a renewable building material with relatively low carbon impact.
Downsides (and Real Ownership Realities)
- High Maintenance: Expect annual cleaning, staining, or oiling, as well as periodic rot and splinter checks. For those considering wood, our seasonal maintenance guide is essential.
- Shorter Life Span: Pressure-treated pine often lasts 10–15 years. Cedar will stretch to 15–25 if maintained.
- Warping and Splinters: Saskatchewan’s shifting temperatures can take a physical toll on even the best lumber.
- Pest Issues: Without regular care, insects (think ants and termites) may move in.
- Potential Quality Variability: Each board is unique, meaning some may contain knots, checks, or unpredictable colour variations.
Best Uses: Situations Where Each Option Wins
Composite Wood Shines When...
- You want a deck that just works year after year with minimal fuss. Composite is for busy families who’d rather spend weekends enjoying the deck than refinishing it.
- Your deck is close to the ground or a pool. Water, snow, and splashes don’t faze composite (but can forever warp and rot standard lumber).
- You want a modern look or trending colour. Check out what’s hot in our Decking Trends page for inspiration on contemporary tones, profiles, and textures.
- Accessibility and safety matter. Composite’s consistent surface is splinter-free and can be less slippery in wet conditions.
Real Wood Is the Best Pick If...
- You want the authentic, classic look—nothing beats the random grain, scent, and aging of real wood.
- Your budget is tight up front, but you’re handy and ready to commit to annual maintenance. (Or you genuinely enjoy a hands-on approach!)
- The build requires heavy or structural members—framing, posts, and ground contacts are always wood or steel, not composite.
- You want the option to sand and refinish—wood can be rehabilitated or restyled almost endlessly if you change your mind.
- Environmental sourcing is vital—especially with local lumber.
Customer Insight: What We See in Real Projects
Many of our customers first lean toward wood for immediate savings, but are swayed by composite’s promise of no more weekend staining, peels, or mould issues. The typical savings in time and annual maintenance for an average deck can be significant, and composite’s long-term cost can be lower. Still, for builder purists, heritage homes, and some custom projects, there’s a magic to real wood that’s hard to replace. We’re happy to help you compare side-by-side in our showrooms and walk you through current decking trends to help visualize your options.
Summary: Side-by-Side Comparison Table
| Feature | Composite Wood | Real Wood |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Wood fibres + plastic resins | Sawn lumber |
| Lifespan (surface boards) | 25–30+ years | 10–25 years |
| Maintenance Cost (avg deck) | Low (just cleaning, $50–$150/yr) | High (stain, repairs, $350–$700/yr) |
| Upfront Cost | Medium–high | Low–high (depends on species) |
| Surface Heat | Higher | Lower |
| Best For | Low-maintenance, harsh climates, modern designs, splinter-free safety | Classic style, budget projects, custom refinishing, structural framing |
FAQ: Your Questions Answered
- Is composite deck material fade-proof? While high-quality composite retains its colour longer than wood, constant, direct prairie sunshine can still fade some hues slightly over decades. For most, this is negligible, but lighter colours tend to stay truer, as we discuss on our Decking Trends page.
- Does composite ever need to be sealed or stained? No. Part of the appeal is a factory finish that never needs coatings or touch-ups.
- Can I mix composite and wood on the same project? Absolutely. Many decks use wooden frames (for strength and code compliance) and composite surfaces for beauty and longevity.
- I want a specific colour or grain. What do you recommend? The variety of composite styles is growing each year—browse our display boards or see our product pages for the latest colour and texture innovations.
Our Final Advice—and How to Go Further
When you’re weighing composite wood vs real wood, there’s no universal “best.” It’s about you: your climate zone, design vision, weekend priorities, and budget. At The Ultimate Deck Shop, we stock everything from the most rugged composite brands (like Deckorators Vista Dunewood) to beautiful grades of cedar and pressure-treated lumber. If you’re looking for more inspiration, see our roundups of current decking trends for the latest material designs, colour stories, and project photos straight from our clients across Saskatchewan and beyond.
Ready to dive deeper or start your project? Drop by our Regina or Saskatoon locations, or browse our online store. We’re always happy to advise—so you get a deck that fits not just today’s trends, but your life for years to come.
